The difference between managing and leading people is greater than most people realize. Managing and leading are different but very important skills to have. The best leaders know how and when to use whichever skill set is appropriate for the occasion.
By definition, management is the process of dealing with or controlling things. This could mean telling people what to do and controlling their actions and directing them in order for them to get something done.
Terms Describing Managers:
- Control
- Direct
- Monitor
- Enforce
Control
Managers have a certain level of control in the workplace, as they are responsible for overseeing the work of their team and ensuring that goals are met. However, it is important to note that this control should not be excessive or abusive, and should be used in a constructive and supportive manner.
Effective managers use their control to provide direction, set expectations, delegate tasks, and provide resources to their team members. They also have the ability to make decisions and take action when needed, such as addressing performance issues or making changes to processes.
However, it is important for managers to recognize the importance of collaboration and teamwork, and not to rely solely on their control to achieve success. Encouraging open communication, involving team members in decision-making, and promoting a culture of trust and respect can help to create a more balanced and productive workplace.
Direct
Directing employees is an important responsibility of managers. They need to create a clear vision and set expectations for their team members, delegate tasks, provide feedback, and ensure that everyone is working towards the same goals.
When directing employees, it is important for managers to provide clear instructions and guidance. They should communicate in a way that is easy to understand and be available to answer any questions or concerns. Managers should also provide regular feedback on performance, both positive and constructive, to help their employees grow and improve.
In addition, managers should be able to motivate and inspire their employees to achieve their best work. This can be done through recognition, providing opportunities for growth and development, and creating a positive work environment. When employees feel supported and valued, they are more likely to be engaged and productive.
Ultimately, directing employees is about setting expectations, providing guidance and feedback, and creating a positive work environment that helps everyone achieve their goals.
Monitor
Monitoring employees is an important responsibility of managers. It involves keeping track of the work that employees are doing, ensuring that they are meeting expectations and deadlines, and identifying any areas where they may need additional support or training.
When monitoring employees, it is important for managers to establish clear performance metrics and communicate them effectively to their team members. They should also be able to identify any gaps in performance and work with employees to develop plans for improvement.
While monitoring employees, managers should also be mindful of the need to respect employees’ privacy and autonomy. They should avoid micromanaging or unnecessarily monitoring every aspect of their work. Instead, they should focus on providing support and guidance where needed, while also allowing employees the space they need to do their best work.
Finally, it is important that managers use monitoring as an opportunity to recognize and reward employees who are doing exceptional work. By highlighting successes and providing positive feedback, managers can help employees feel valued and motivated to continue performing at a high level.
Enforce
Enforcement is another important responsibility of managers. It involves ensuring that employees follow company policies, procedures, and best practices to ensure safety, compliance, and ethical behavior.
When enforcing policies and procedures, managers must be clear and consistent in their expectations. They should communicate policies and procedures effectively to their team members and provide guidance on how to comply with them. Managers should also monitor compliance and take corrective action when necessary.
In addition, managers must be fair and impartial in their enforcement of policies and procedures. They should avoid showing favoritism or singling out individual employees for enforcement actions. Instead, they should apply policies and procedures consistently across the organization.
Finally, it is important for managers to be aware of any potential legal or ethical issues that may arise when enforcing policies and procedures. They should be familiar with relevant laws and regulations and take steps to ensure that their enforcement actions are in compliance with these requirements.
Overall, enforcement is an important responsibility of managers to ensure that employees are following company policies and procedures to maintain a safe and compliant workplace.
In contrast, lead means to guide somebody in order for them to get things done. This could mean communicating the leader’s direction and allowing the people to follow it on their own.
Terms Describing Leaders:
- Guide
- Motivate
- Influence
- Enable
Guide
Guiding is a key responsibility of leaders. It involves providing direction, support, and inspiration to their team members to help them achieve their goals and reach their full potential.
When guiding team members, leaders must have a clear vision and communicate it effectively to their team. They should be able to articulate the organization’s purpose, values, and goals, as well as provide guidance on how to achieve them. Leaders should also be able to adapt their guidance to the needs and strengths of individual team members.
In addition to providing direction, leaders must also provide support to their team members. This may involve providing resources, coaching, and feedback to help team members develop their skills and reach their full potential. Leaders should also be available to answer questions and provide guidance when team members encounter challenges.
Finally, leaders must inspire and motivate their team members to achieve their goals. They should lead by example, demonstrating the values and behaviors they expect from their team. Leaders should also recognize and reward team members for their accomplishments and provide opportunities for growth and development.
Overall, guiding is an essential responsibility of leaders to help their team members achieve their goals and reach their full potential.
Motivate
Motivating team members is a crucial responsibility of leaders. It involves inspiring and energizing employees to work together towards a common goal and to achieve outstanding results.
To motivate their team members, leaders must first understand what drives each individual. This requires building a strong relationship with each team member and getting to know their strengths, weaknesses, and interests. Once leaders have this understanding, they can tailor their motivational strategies to each team member.
One common approach to motivating team members is to set challenging but achievable goals. Leaders can work with their team members to set goals that are aligned with the organization’s mission and vision and provide regular feedback on progress towards these goals. When team members achieve their goals, leaders should celebrate their successes and recognize their contributions.
Another key aspect of motivating team members is providing a positive and supportive work environment. Leaders should foster a culture of respect, collaboration, and open communication, where team members feel valued and supported. They should also provide opportunities for skill development and career advancement, to help team members grow and develop their talents.
Finally, leaders can motivate their team members by leading by example. When leaders demonstrate enthusiasm, dedication, and passion for their work, it can inspire team members to do the same. Leaders should also model the behaviors they expect from their team members, such as accountability, integrity, and a commitment to excellence.
Overall, motivating team members is an important responsibility of leaders to create a positive and productive work environment, and to achieve outstanding results.
Influence
Leaders have a significant influence on their team members, and on the success of the organization as a whole. They shape the culture, values, and direction of the organization, and have the power to inspire, motivate, and guide their team members toward achieving their goals.
One way that leaders influence their team members is by setting an example. Leaders who demonstrate strong values, ethics, and work habits can inspire their team members to do the same. They can also model the behaviors they expect from their team members, such as accountability, honesty, and a commitment to excellence.
Leaders also have the power to inspire and motivate their team members. They can communicate a compelling vision for the organization, and inspire team members to work together toward achieving that vision. They can also recognize and celebrate the accomplishments of team members, and provide opportunities for skill development and career advancement.
In addition, leaders can influence the culture of the organization. They can create a positive and supportive work environment, where team members feel valued and respected. They can also foster a culture of innovation and continuous improvement, where team members are encouraged to take risks and try new things.
Overall, leaders have a significant influence on their team members and on the success of the organization. By setting an example, inspiring and motivating team members, and shaping the culture of the organization, leaders can create a positive and productive work environment, and achieve outstanding results.
Enable
Leaders play a crucial role in enabling their team members to reach their full potential and achieve outstanding results. By providing the necessary resources, guidance, and support, leaders can empower their team members to take on new challenges, develop their skills, and succeed in their roles.
One way that leaders enable their team members is by providing clear goals and expectations. Leaders can work with their team members to define specific and measurable goals, and provide regular feedback on progress towards these goals. This helps team members to stay focused and motivated and enables them to make the necessary adjustments to achieve success.
Another way that leaders enable their team members is by providing the necessary resources and support. Leaders can ensure that their team members have access to the tools, training, and information they need to perform their jobs effectively. They can also provide guidance and mentorship to help team members navigate challenges and develop their skills.
Leaders can also enable their team members by fostering a culture of collaboration and teamwork. By creating a supportive and inclusive work environment, leaders can encourage team members to share ideas, work together, and leverage each other’s strengths to achieve shared goals.
Finally, leaders can enable their team members by recognizing and celebrating their accomplishments. By acknowledging the contributions and successes of team members, leaders can boost morale, inspire team members to continue to strive for excellence and create a culture of excellence and achievement.
Overall, leaders have a crucial role in enabling their team members to reach their full potential and achieve outstanding results. By providing clear goals and expectations, necessary resources and support, fostering a culture of collaboration and teamwork, and recognizing and celebrating accomplishments, leaders can empower their team members to succeed in their roles and contribute to the success of the organization.
The Difference Between Managing and Leading in the Work Environment
In any work environment, the roles of managers and leaders are crucial. However, their methods and impact can be quite different. Let’s get into these differences and understand which approach might be more effective for you and your team.
Management: A Numbers Game
Managers often see teams as a collection of numbers. Their focus is on metrics and production rates. At times, this can actually backfire. Imagine a boss who keeps interrupting workers to get updates. This constant monitoring not only slows down the workflow but also dampens the team’s morale. This approach may maintain steady production, but it rarely, if ever, inspires.
In the Air Force, we learned that mission success often depends on giving people the freedom to do their jobs without micromanagement. Trust is key. The same goes for managing any team. A balance needs to be struck between monitoring and allowing your team the room to breathe and succeed.
Leadership: Building People Up
Leaders operate differently. They focus on building people up, enhancing their skills, and providing emotional support. Picture a leader who takes a few extra minutes to talk to an employee about personal issues. This leader knows that a happy and mentally healthy worker is more productive and innovative. Leaders don’t just aim for short-term gains. They invest in long-term growth, knowing that their team’s success is their success.
In my time as a leader, fostering an environment where individuals felt valued made all the difference. Engaged and supported people naturally step up and often exceed expectations.
Circle of Power vs. Circle of Influence
Now, consider the different spheres in which managers and leaders operate. Managers have a circle of power. They’re surrounded by subordinates who follow orders because they have to. Fear of job loss can be a strong motivator, but it doesn’t foster creativity or loyalty.
Leaders, on the other hand, cultivate a circle of influence. Their followers choose to listen and follow because they respect and trust their leader. This voluntary allegiance is much stronger and more enduring than the compelled obedience of subordinates.
I’ve seen firsthand that influence is more powerful than authority. Genuine connections lead to real loyalty and sustained success.
Finding Your Own Path
By understanding these differences, you can start to see where you might be able to incorporate more leadership into your management style. Remember, everyone’s journey is unique. Use these insights to develop a style that works best for you and your team.
Leadership isn’t about having all the answers. It’s about asking the right questions and guiding others to find their own solutions. Your purpose-driven action can inspire and elevate those around you, creating a work environment built on trust, respect, and lasting success.
How do Leaders Get People to Follow Them?
- Lead by example. If a boss is not doing the right things or willing to work hard, those underneath them are going to lose respect and not want to put in any extra effort.
- Take a few extra minutes to find out what is going in people’s lives. Personal issues can really affect how a person performs at work.
- Find out what motivates people. This can be public recognition, money, prizes, or sometimes just a simple good job is enough.
- Give constant feedback to your employees. Good or bad. Many times people don’t know if they are doing something wrong. They can’t fix what they don’t know even if it may be obvious to you.
The difference between managing and leading people can be the difference between employees staying or leaving. A workplace is a lot more productive when subordinates want to work for their boss.
Did you enjoy this article on the difference between managing and leading? Please share and subscribe below.